Tuesday, September 28, 2010

Education

Recently, I've encountered an issue with courses; I'm part-time enrolled in the Washington Virtual Academy, which offers online courses, and I also take two electives at Redmond Junior High. However, recently, the school districts informed me that, because I was over the allotted "FTE," or full-time equivalency, that I would not be allowed to take one of my courses. This is the letter I wrote to Chip Kimball, superintendent at Lake Washington School District:

----

Dear Mr. Kimball,

My name’s Adora Svitak. I am twelve years old, and I’m currently dually enrolled in the Washington Virtual Academy, an online public school, and Redmond Junior High in Lake Washington School District. I’m writing to you today because of an issue I’ve encountered in my dual enrollment. I am taking Creative Cooking and Drama at Redmond Junior High School in addition to my online courses, and the two electives are a wonderful addition. I enjoy both very much. As a student taking Honors social studies and language arts classes, the published author of two books, and a speaker, literacy advocate, and presenter (I teach students every day via video conferencing about reading and writing, and I will be receiving the National Education Association, or NEA, award for service to public education), I think it can be agreed that I am capable of taking the two elective courses.

However, Redmond Junior High and the Lake Washington School District have informed me that I will not be allowed to take both Cooking and Drama, and that I will have to drop one (as I am already taking French at my online school). I’m assuming that the course limits rule was set up because regular students attending a brick-and-mortar school every day would not be able to attend more than six courses. But because of my dual enrollment, it is possible for me to take more courses than are usually allowed.  Rules, especially those in education, should be set up to benefit the student and help us reach our full potential. In this case, the rules are a limiting force, preventing me from learning to the extent of my ability.

My mom, Joyce Svitak, placed a call to your office, where she was told that it wasn’t about the courses, it was about the money. I understand that in these times, school districts have to watch their budgets. However, both of the classes that I am in had room; the teachers are getting paid the same salary nevertheless; I’m actually paying a lab fee for Creative Cooking. They are still printing out the same number of rubrics and assignments. One student really doesn’t make a difference budget-wise.

I am okay with not receiving credits or FTE for taking the extra elective course at Redmond Junior High. But I would ask that Lake Washington School District provide me the opportunity to take it.

Thank you,
Adora Svitak

---

To me, this is just one example of what's wrong in education. In a time when we are facing dropout rates and such an epidemic of kids not wanting to learn, they hyperventilate about one student who loves to learn, taking one extra class, and treat it as an "urgent issue." You can pin it down to money, but the teacher's salary isn't dictated by how many students there are in a class. The heating costs don't go up for one more student. The fact that they trouble themselves over tiny issues like this is simply evidence of bureaucracy--and how adult-centric an institution designed to benefit students really is.

-Adora

P.S.Woohoo! Today, Washington Virtual Academy, my online public school, made a compromise, allowing me to continue taking my electives.

Thursday, September 23, 2010

TEDxRedmond

To those of you who have been following TEDxRedmond, we successfully concluded our event on Saturday. I'm glad to say that it definitely had a huge impact beyond the Kodiak Theater (in the Microsoft Conference Center), reaching into schools, classrooms, homes, and communities around the city of Redmond, the State of Washington, and hopefully, around the nation and the world.

Videos will be coming soon!

I want to share some wonderful comments from attendees. One of our audience members, ten-year-old Apoorva Chowdhary, sent me an email after the event:


Dear Adora,
       Thank you for organizing the TEDx event. I really enjoyed it and it was very inspiring. It makes me think about what kind of plans I should set for myself, and also makes me think what I should do to help people in the future.
       I love how you have the thought that teachers should learn from their students, because I totally agree. And after seeing the TEDx event, I am thinking of starting a blog. I don’t know what it’s going to be about yet, but I will figure out soon. And even though I have never created one before I think I can. My opinion is that it’s good to try new things.
       It would be awesome if I could put my footprint on the world (like you said). After the event, I was really thinking about how it would be if I could do that. I came to the conclusion that it would be awesome, and I totally should. What I really liked about the TEDx event was that it probably inspired other people to do that too.
       Oh I forgot to introduce myself! My name is Apoorva Chowdhary, and I am ten years old. At the current time I do lots of after school activities. I have played piano for about 5 years, and I have also done martial arts for 5 years. I do swimming too, and I am at the pre-competition level. Over the years I have also done tennis and volleyball camps too. Lastly, I am running for vice-president in my student council because I am in sixth grade and it’s about time I get into my school’s student council.
       I hope you reply to my letter. You are really truthfully inspiring to me and I think you are a great role-model. And your sister was amazing on the piano too. Thank you so much for organizing the TEDx event, I loved it!
Sincerely,
Apoorva
As promised, Apoorva did start a blog! I encourage everyone to check it out (and follow!), at http://apoorvachowdharysblog.blogspot.com/ 

Zoe Sprankle was one of our TEDxRedmond performers. She both spoke and sang on the TEDxRedmond stage. Her dad, Bob Sprankle, podcasted and wrote on his blog, Bit by Bit (as well as on the TechLearning blog) about the TEDxRedmond experience. His open letter to TEDxRedmond's speakers and presenters touched us all:

An Open Letter to #TEDxRedmond Presenters
by Bob Sprankle
(cross-posted at TechLearning)
Dear TEDxRedmond Presenters (Adora, Adrianna, Alec, Austin, Brigitte, Cayle, Jason, Jessica, Jordan, Kelsey, Maddy, Madison, Maya, Noah, Oliver, Olivia, Perry, Priya, Sierra, Simone, Zach, Zoe),
As I write this, I’m still shaking off a bit of jet lag after this past Saturday’sTEDxRedmondconference and have almost gotten back to East-coast time, but without a doubt my heart and thoughts are still back in Redmond, Washington as I continue to process all of your amazing presentations. In doing so, I wanted to reflect on some of my own thoughts and realizations with you in this open letter.

First, I’d like to thank you all for giving me one of the greatest experiences of my life. This was undoubtedly the most amazing and important conferences I ever had the privilege to attend. Sure, I was there as a proud dad (see Zoë Sprankle), but I was also there as an educator, a learner, and even as a podcaster, catching some of the most cherished interviews with students ever (it saddens me that I wasn’t able to interview you all and I hope that opportunity presents itself at some future date).
The fact that this conference was entirely created, presented, and attended by students under 16 years old is a monumental accomplishment. Of course there were adult “fingerprints” of support abounding (big thanks to all the Sponsors who helped pave the way), but you all did the real deal. From the students who organized the event, to the presenters who got up there and “blew our minds,” to the attendees who stayed for the entire day (longer than most regular school days), I tip my hat to you.
I’ve been to many education conferences and every time I go, I ask, “Where are the students?” Recently at the Building Learning Communities Conference in Boston there was a student presence (Adora, Zoë, as well as a group of high school students helping to run the conference), and the K-12 Online Conference has started a Student Voices strand this year, so it’s not as if it hasn’t happened before. But this conference was entirely “student-centric” and I applaud the fact that we adults were not even allowed in the main room and had to watch the event via telesync in separate rooms.
So Kudos and great Thanks to you all.
Secondly, I want to tell you that you have inspired my students and the teachers that I’ve been able to share TEDxRedmond with. So far, I’ve only showed them your pictures and accomplishments and told stories I heard from you or what I learned about your accomplishments. My students are chomping at the bit to finally get to view the videos recorded from the conference (I hope they get posted soon!), and all of your accomplishments and work have served as great examples of what doing one’s best, following one’s passions or dreams, and not giving up can look like. This is a great gift as we all start a new school year and set high goals and define what excellence means.
Thirdly, I want to tell you that I’ve revealed to every one of my students that you have no “magical, super powers,” and that you are students just like them and that they can be great just like you. Students have identified what elements have added to your success in your endeavors, what it is that you all have in common. Here’s what they came up with: that you have done meaningful work; that you are passionate about that work; that you stuck with it; and that you followed your dreams. From that conversation, it was an easy jump to ask students what they are passionate about; what change they want to make; how they’re going to stick with it. All of you serve as undeniable evidence that they can accomplish their dreams, just like you all have.
And lastly, I want to tell you something that you might not have heard on Saturday as you were busy presenting, or listening to co-presenters in the green room. I got to talk to a lot of people during the short breaks we were given—parents and children alike. Some of these conversations will be presented on the podcast along with the interviews I was able to do with you. Here’s the thing that I kept asking the student participants that I want you to know about. I pointed out to them that they had been sitting for hours listening to you all and that they had given up their Saturday to come to this learning experience that lasted longer than most of their normal school days. I asked them if they had had enough; if they were ready to get out of there (since it had been such a long day). And here’s what they all said to me: “No way! I want more of this! This is amazing!”
I asked them a follow-up question: “Do you feel the same way about your school day?” And each one took a pause, gave me a quizzical look, and gave the same honest answer: “No way. Not at all.”
I followed up by asking why this was so and got a variety of answers, but it was clear that many of them were still formulating a response, and some were not able yet to articulate what the difference was between your conference and their schools’ offerings.
This is one of the biggest “take-aways” from the conference for me and I need all of you (as well as all those that are reading this open letter) to help answer that question. Please. Help us teachers, principals, superintendents, parents, board members, legislatures, president, etc. understand why you were all able to hold students’ attentions for a very long day and have them begging for more, when most of our schools are struggling to keep students in them, or engaged, or even interested.
When Adora asked at the end of the day, “What have we learned?” a young students answered —and forgive me if my paraphrase doesn’t have it exactly correct— that she learned that other students from around the world were thinking and worrying and talking about the same things that she was. That was one of the most salient quotes from the whole day, and it won’t leave me alone.
I need to find out why she wasn’t able to know this before. I need to find out how we can become better connected across the globe so students know we are sharing the same thoughts, goals, worries, passions. I need to work towards helping my students become even more connected with their own passions, with other students like them from around the world, and with the confidence and belief that they can change the world, just as you have all done.
You have laid a huge body of indisputable evidence at our feet. The success of TEDxRedmond proves that students want to and are capable of carrying off huge feats, able and interested in educating and learning from each other, and committed to meaningful and purposeful work, even if they have to go outside of their school’s curriculum to make that happen.
You have given me an extraordinary burst of hope for our futures, as I am confident you have done to thousands of others.
Again, I thank you.
Sincerely,
Bob Sprankle

From the buzz on Twitter, Facebook, and the positive emails we've received, I think it's evident that TEDxRedmond has had an impact. It's only when we can get everyone involved in the discussion like this that there will truly be "Power to the Students."

-Adora Svitak, Curator and Host, TEDxRedmond
Thanks to Bob Sprankle and Apoorva Chowdhary for comments.